Decisions by Policy Group

According to Policy on Policy, Policy Group can make decisions concerning policies. This list tracks formal (voted) decisions made in most-recent-first order. See also Policy and DecisionNumbers.

p20141008 CCA to POLICY

Eva: Resolved,

Aye:

Grégoire, Benedikt, Eva, vv01f, Brian, Hendrik, Alex, Ron, Marc, BenBE, Werner, Juergen, Guillaume, Ruediger, Ken, Dirk, Marcus, Reinhard, Magu, Felix

Abstain:

Nay:

Motion CARRIED. Consensus of 20:0 reached. Voting closed at 2014-10-15

p20140731 Move 7 Policies and 4 Subsidary Policies from DRAFT to POLICY

Eva: Resolved,

  1. Policy on Policy ("PoP" => COD1)

  2. Configuration-Control Specification ("CCS" => COD2)

  3. Certification Practice Statement ("CPS" => COD6)

  4. Dispute Resolution Policy ("DRP" => COD7)

  5. Security Policy ("SP" => COD8)

  6. Organisation Assurance Policy ("OAP" => COD11)

  7. Root Distribution License ("RDL" => COD14)

  8. Organisation Assurance Subsidary Policy - Germany (COD11.DE)
  9. Organisation Assurance Subsidary Policy - Europe (COD11.EU)
  10. Organisation Assurance Subsidary Policy - Australia (COD11.AU)
  11. TTP-Assisted Assurance Policy ("TTP-Assist" => COD13.2)

The documents can be found: https://svn.cacert.org/CAcert/Policies/ControlledDocumentList.html

However at least the PoP is NOT posted correctly there. See also below where the policies went to draft.

Aye:

Eva, Grégoire, Benedikt, Werner, Magu, BenBE, Juergen, Marcus, Marc, Ken, Ted

Abstain:

Nay:

Ulrich

Motion CARRIED. Rough consensus of 11:1 reached. Voting closed at 2014-08-14

Vote opened: 2014-07-31. Motion posted here open until: 2014-08-14

p20140709 CCA update to DRAFT

Eva: Resolved,

A short overview of the changes: [will be added soon, probably 2014-07-10 evening UTC, but is also contained in above link]

Aye:

Benny, Werner, AlexUK, Janis, Dirk, Eva, Felix, Hendrik, Benedikt, Magu, MOH, Marcus, Juergen, Ted, Guillaume, Grégoire, Ken S., Bernd

Abstain:

Nay:

Motion CARRIED. Consensus of 18:0 reached. Voting closed 2014-07-27.

p20140427 Eva for Policy Officer

Iang: Resolved,

Aye:

Iang, Magu, BenBE, Bernd, Eelco Hotting, Alex, Brian, Ron Pettigrew, Pieter, Ted, Lambert

Abstain:

Nay:

Motion CARRIED. Consensus of 11:0 reached. Voting closed 20140508.

p20130223 Several minor changes to PoP to DRAFT

Ulrich: Resolved,

that we update Policy on Policy (PoP) as proposed under https://svn.cacert.org/CAcert/Policies/PolicyOnPolicy.html (markers in blue) with the following changes:

  1. to update the "old" style header to the "new" style header
    • change from:
           PoP                Iang
           POLICY p200800204.1                20080309
           COD1
                   Policy on Policy
    • change to:
           Name: PoP COD1
           Status: POLICY p200800204.1
           Editor: Iang 20080309                      [PoP Status - POLICY] x1)
           Changes: 20100507, 20130223                [PoP Status - DRAFT]  x1)
           Licence: CC-by-sa+DRP
      
              x1) as the POLICY and DRAFT pictures
  2. changes from 20100507 in section 0
    • change from:
           0. Preliminaries
      
           Policy on Policy adopts the IETF model of 'rough consensus' to create
           CAcert documents within the open [cacert-policy] mail list forum.
    • change to:
           0. Preliminaries
      
           Policy on Policy adopts the IETF model of 'rough consensus' to create
           CAcert documents within the open CAcert Policy Group mail list forum.  x2)
      
           x2) "mail list forum" with a link to
             https://lists.cacert.org/wws/info/cacert-policy
  3. changes from 20100507 in section 1.3
    • change from:
           1.3 The policies so created are generally binding on
               CAcert, registered users and related parties
    • change to:
           1.3 The policies so created are generally binding on
               CAcert Inc., members under CAcert Community Agreement (CCA => COD9)
               and other related parties under other agreements.
  4. changes from 20100507 in section 1.4
    • change from:
           1.4 The Policy Officer manages all policies and the policy group.
           The policy group is formed on the open mailing list known as
           [cacert-policy], and is to be open to all Community Members of CAcert.
    • change to:
           1.4 The Policy Officer manages all policies and the policy group.
           The policy group is formed on the open mailing list known as
           CAcert Policy Group, and is to be open to all Community Members of CAcert.
  5. section PoP 2.5 to add the minutea changes section, as known from p20100306 - minor changes to PoP
    • adding:
           2.5 Editors may make the following changes, where it is clear
               that the change does not change the policy:
      
                o fixes to errors in grammar and spelling,
                o anchors, HTML errors, URLs & formatting,
                o COD numbers and other references, and
                o other minutiae, as agreed under 2.3.
      
           Such changes to be notified to the policy group, and to be
           folded into effect, etc, without further ado.
  6. proposed changes from 20100507 to section 2.5, now moves to 2.6
    • adding:
           2.6 Documents of lower status (work-in-progress or DRAFT)
               must not be confusable with documents of higher status
               (DRAFT or POLICY). Copies should be eliminated where
               not being worked on.
  7. proposed changes from 20100507 from CCS work -and- recently identified subsection in CPS (9.16.1) (where should policies reside?) to move to PoP
    • adding:
           5.4 POLICY documents are published on the CAcert website
               in plain HTML. Change control must be in place.
  8. point 6.5 to add "A record of decisions is to be maintained."
    • change from:
           6.5 Mailing lists should be archived, and important meetings
               should be minuted.
    • change to:
           6.5 Mailing lists should be archived, and important meetings
               should be minuted. A record of decisions is to be maintained.

Aye:

Ulrich, Guillaume, Hendrik Lehmbruch, Jan, Iang, Werner, Brian, Benedikt, Bernd, Piers, Juergen Bruckner, Marc, KenSchumacher, Michael Muetterlein, Philipp, Martin, Reinhard, Etienne Ruedin, Alex

Abstain:

Nay:

Motion CARRIED. Consensus of 19:0 reached. Voting closed 20130309.

p20130222 PoJAM to POLICY

Ulrich: Resolved,

Aye:

Ulrich, Alex, Iang, Brian, Guillaume, Werner, Jan, Philipp, Megan, Hendrik Lehmbruch, Martin, Bernd, Benedikt, Piers, Juergen Bruckner, Marc, KenSchumacher, Michael Muetterlein, Reinhard, Etienne Ruedin, Andreas

Abstain:

Nay:

Motion CARRIED. Consensus of 21:0 reached. Voting closed 20130309.

p20130116 DRP - drop three references to Board's role in Appeal

Iang: Resolved,

that we delete the following 3 references to Board's role in appeal in Dispute Resolution Policy, having been superceded by the creation of an Arbitrators' forum of appeal in p20110108:

Note that 3.6 has been improved on the fly. Voters can express their lack of consensus on the policy group. Following vote refers to entire package of changes, including the late addition.

Aye:

Iang, Bernd, Piers, Brian, Ted, Uli, Dirk, Guillaume, Jan, Marc, Guy Scharinger, Kenneth van Wyk, Benedikt, Werner, Juergen Bruckner, Philipp, Megan, Alex, KenSchumacher, Reinhard

Abstain:

Nay:

Carsten Scholvien

Motion CARRIED. Voting closed 20130131.

p20121213 DRP - minor changes, excluding controversial issues

Bernd: Resolved,

Brief description of the non-trivial changes:

Aye:

Bernd, Alex, Megan, Werner, Brian, Iang, Sven Andriske, Uli, Guillaume, Nick Bebout, Etienne Ruedin, Reinhard, Marek, Jan, Lambert, Alexander B, Sebastian Juerges, Marc, Guy Scharinger, Ted, Hendrik Lehmbruch, Kenneth van Wyk, Heinz Hiekmann, Ken, Carlos Delmas Bayot, Carsten Scholvien, Dirk, Marcus Mängel, Martin, Philipp

Abstain:

Nay:

Voting opened 20121213. Motion posted. Blog.

Motion CARRIED. Consensus of 30:0. Voting closed 20121221.

p20121113 DRP - minor clarifications to parties, etc

Iang: Resolved,

Brief description of changes:

Aye:

Iang

Abstain:

Nay:

Alex, Werner, Megan, Bernd

Motion FAILED. Voting closed 20121120.

Voting opened 20121113. motion posted.

p20111113 CPS #7.1.2 "Certificate Extensions" adjustments

MichaelTänzer: Resolved,

Aye:

Michael, Pieter, Joost, Jan, Raoul, Guillaume, Ted, Lambert, Marcus Mängel, Sören Kornetzki, Jason Curl, Bernd, Morten Gulbrandsen, Martin, Uli, Andreas, Hendrik Lehmbruch, Werner, Philipp D, Frank, Alexander, Tomáš, Benedikt, Dirk

Abstain:

Nay:

Motion CARRIED. Consensus of 24:0. Voting closed 20111128.

p20110108 DRP #3.4 Appeal handled by Arbitrators

Iang: Resolved,

Aye:

Iang, Nik, Bernd, Lambert, Pieter, Marcus Mängel, Ted, Uli, Philipp D, Guillaume, Morten Gulbrandsen, Faramir, Gero, Brian, Nick Bebout, Tomáš,

Abstain:

Nay:

Motion is CARRIED. Voting closed 20110126.

Voting opened 20110123. voting.

p20101009 Changes to CCA for RDL

Iang: Resolved,

Aye:

Abstain:

Nay:

Uli, Nik, Iang, Martin, Bernd, Iang

Motion is NOT carried. Voting closed 20101024. Requests to postpone from Uli and Nik are treated as NAYS. Motion posted.

p20100913 TTP Assisted Assurance Subpolicy

Ulrich: Resolved,

Aye:

Ulrich, Nik, Iang, Tomáš, Ted, Philipp D, Alejandro Mery, Tom R, Law, Morten Gulbrandsen, Faramir, Pieter, João V, Bernd, Mike J, Alexander, Benedikt, Dirk, Marcus Mängel, Gero, Raymond, Mark Lipscombe, Brian, Martin

Abstain:

Nay:

Motion CARRIED. Consensus of 24:0. Voting closed weekend 20100926.

p20100722 License our Policies under CC-BY-SA-3.0-AU

Iang: Resolved,

See PolicyDrafts/DocumentLicence Alternative 2.

Aye:

Philipp G, Philipp D, Bernd, Martin, Nathan Tuggy, Ulrich,

Abstain:

Nay:

Daniel

Motion CARRIED. Consensus of 6:1. Voting closed weekend 20100801. Request sent to board meeting 20100801. Board agrees!

p20100710 License root under Root Distribution License

Iang: Resolved,

* 3rd paragraph added 20100716, mid-vote, with rough consensus.

Aye:

Sascha Thomas Spreitzer, Tomáš, Ulrich, Philipp D, Morten Gulbrandsen, Pieter, Brian, Philipp G, Nathan Tuggy, Bernd, Andreas, Mario, Alexander, Mark Lipscombe, Martin,

Abstain:

Faramir,

Nay:

hugi, Peter Williams, Daniel

Motion CARRIED. Consensus of 15:3. Voting closed weekend 20100724.

p20100627 License root under CC-BY-ND

Sascha Thomas Spreitzer: Resolved,

Aye:

Sascha Thomas Spreitzer, Daniel, Dieter, Roberto, Gregory Engels, hugi, ernie, Mathieu,

Abstain:

Morten Gulbrandsen

Nay:

Iang, Philipp D, Pieter, Brian, Bernd, Ulrich, Guillaume

Adverse comments seen from Kyle and Nathan, but no call.

NOT Carried. With 8 to 6 in favour, rough consensus is not established. Closed 20100710.

p20100624 CCA defining "CAcert Services"

Daniel: Resolved, {1},

Aye:

Abstain:

Lambert

Nay:

Mark Lipscombe, Bernd, Iang, Ulrich, Philipp D,

NOT Carried.

p20100510 Security Policy to DRAFT

Iang: Resolved,

Aye:

Iang, Philipp D, Brian, Faramir, Philipp G, Hans Verbeek, Pieter, Morten Gulbrandsen, Mario, Tomáš, Martin, Bernd, Wytze, Andreas, Ulrich, Markus, Dominik, Alexander, Dirk, Michael

Abstain:

Nay:

Motion CARRIED. Voting closed weekend 20100606.

p20100426 CCS to DRAFT

Iang: Resolved,

Aye:

Philipp D, Ulrich, Iang, Alexander, Morten Gulbrandsen, Brian, Michael, Lambert, Faramir, Mario, Philipp G, Pieter, Tomáš

Abstain:

Nay:

Andreas, hugi,

Motion is carried, 13 to 2. Closed 20100517.

p20100401 VETO takes a policy to WIP Document

Iang: Resolved,

Aye:

Nathan Tuggy, Faramir, Dieter, Philipp, Roberto, Mathieu, Lambert, hugi, Barry, Pieter, Brian, Michael, Kyle, Tomáš

Abstain:

Nay:

Mario, Ulrich

Motion is Carried, 14 to 2, on 20100411.

p20100327 Remove Board background checks from DRAFT Security Policy -- VACATED

Daniel Black: Identified that board background checks conflict with Association Rules

By rough consensus the issue of background checks of board members is resolved as follows: This purported decision does not reach the standards of Policy on Policy and and is vacated 20100330. If any further deliberations are required they should be done by a proper vote before policy group. Board should abstain. Elsewise, refer to dispute resolution procedures in PoP.

For removal

Wytze van der Raay

For removal, Board, Conflicted

Daniel Black Mario Mark Nick Bebout Ernie

Against Removal

Barry Berg

Materially misrecorded

Guillaume ROMAGNY Pieter van Emmerik Andreas Bürki ulrich(?)

Board, conflicted, no vote cast

Iang

p20100326 Security Policy to remain in DRAFT

Iang: Resolved,

  1. Keep SP in DRAFT for another period, and re-work those BLUE sections.

  2. Accept the BLUE, and go to POLICY.

  3. Discard the BLUE as not voted, and go to POLICY.

  4. Or?

Choice 1, Aye:

hugi, ernie, Daniel, UlrichSchroeter, Michael, Nathan Tuggy, Faramir, Lambert

Choice 2, Aye:

Choice 3, Aye:

Choice 4, Aye:

Vote closed 20100326. Security Policy remains in DRAFT.

p20100306 Policy Officer makes minor adjustments

Iang: Resolved,

Choice 1, Aye:

Choice 2, Aye:

Choice 3, Aye:

Iang, Morten Gulbrandsen, Ulrich, Pieter, Raoul Martin Lambert Brian

Choice 4, Aye:

Vote closed 20100306. Option 3 is carried with 8 Ayes. Policy Officer may make minor adjustments:

p20100120 Assurance Policy: require government ID

Alexander: Resolved,

Vote Aye if you want the AP to be clear about what is allowed and what is not, and specifically require a match with government issued ID.

Vote Nay if you prefer to leave this an open question and allow names which are not in government issued ID.

Aye:

Alexander, Morten Gulbrandsen,

Abstain:

Nay:

Iang, Ulrich, Ted, Mario, Pieter, Faramir

Not Carried.

p20100119 PoJAM to DRAFT

Ulrich: Resolved,

Junior Assurers / Members, also known as PoJAM, here:

Aye:

Mario, Alexander, Morten Gulbrandsen, Dominik, Ulrich, Joost, Iang, Tomáš, Ted, Faramir, Brian, Martin, Nathan Tuggy, Raoul

Abstain:

Nay:

Hans Verbeek, Marty

Vote closed 20100130. The decision is carried with 14 Ayes, 2 Nays. PoJAM moves to DRAFT

p20100113 Stop issuing class3 certificates

Daniel: Resolved,

Aye:

Daniel, Philipp D, Guillaume, Pieter, hugi

Middle:

Dominik, Alexander

Nay:

Iang Raoul, Gero, Mario, Philipp G, Ted, Lambert, Tomáš, Faramir, Morten Gulbrandsen

Voting closed on 20100119 due to new information m20100117.3. Not carried, NO consensus.

p20091108 CPS to drop assurer critieria and allow IDN certificates in specified TLD or single script character sets

Daniel: Resolved,

In: 1.4.5. Roots and Names

the text ", IDN" is to be removed from the table.

Add after section 3.1.6 the following text:

3.1.7. International Domain Names

Certificates containing International Domain Names, being those containing a ACE prefix (RFC3490 Section 5), will only be issued to domains satisfying one or more of the following conditions:

Email address containing International Domain Names in the domain portion of the email address will also be required to satisfy one of the above conditions.

The following is a list of accepted TLD Registrars:

(insert table from http://www.mozilla.org/projects/security/tld-idn-policy-list.html)

This criteria will apply to the email address and server host name fields for all certificate types.

The CAcert Inc. Board has the authority to decide to add or remove accepted TLD Registrars on this list.

In 3.2.2. Authentication of Individual Identity remove the portion of the table containing:

IDN  |  Can create International Domain Name (IDN) certificates

Aye:

Daniel, Andreas, Lambert, Nick Bebout, Thomas Kuehn, Werner, Marcus, Brian, Tomáš, Michael

Abstain:

Nay:

Carried. Vote closed 20091115 with consensus of 10 Ayes. Implemented!

p20091106 CPS to be placed on the main website

Iang: Resolved,

Aye:

Lambert, Faramir, Iang, Brian, Philipp D, Pieter, Werner, Nick Bebout, Daniel, Andreas, Tomáš, Mark Lipscombe, Ted

Abstain:

Nay:

Carried. Vote closed 20091115 with consensus of 13 Ayes.

p20090706 CPS to DRAFT

Philipp: Resolved,

AYE:

Maurice, Ted, Lambert, Werner, Daniel, Nick Bebout, Iang, Faramir, Brian, Tomáš, Philipp, Alejandro Mery, Guillaume, Robert Cruikshank, Greg, Evaldo

Abstain:

Nay:

Vote closed 20090706 with consensus of 16 AYES.

p20090327 Security Policy to DRAFT

Philipp: resolved,

Within the Security Policy there are a lot of references to the Security Manual. If you want to have a look at the current state of that, you can find it at SecurityManual

AYE:

Philipp, Alejandro Mery, Maurice, Rasika Dayarathna, Pete Stephenson, Greg, Sam, Tomáš, Lambert, Faramir, Pieter.

Abstain:

Nay:

Vote closed 20090327 with consensus of 11 Ayes.

p20090218.1 Add Danish SVR trade office registrar to the OA sub-policy Europe table of accepted trade office registrars

Teus: Resolved,

AYE:

Asbjørn, Peter, Svenne

Abstain:

Nay:

p20090210.1 Add Belgian KBO trade office registrar to the OA sub-policy Europe table of accepted trade office registrars

Teus: Resolved,

Aye:

Alexander, Wim

Abstain:

Nay:

p20090105.2 Assurance Policy status: POLICY

Philipp: Resolved,

AYE:

Philipp D, Nick Bebout, John Moore III, Alejandro Mery, Teus

Abstain:

Nay:

(AP is now on main website.)

p20090105.1 Methods to check Domain/Email Control and Ownership

Philipp: Resolved,

  1. CAcert will check whether an individual has control of the email address requested for certificate inclusion within 24 hours a client certificate is requested and may check at any time thereafter.
  2. In order to get a certificate issued by the *Community Member Subroot* the member must have been assured at least once and received at least one point. This ensures that the member has physically signed the CCA.
  3. In order to have their Name included in a client certificate or have a certificate issued by the *Assured Community Member Subroot* the member has to have been assured to at least 50 points.
  4. In order to have a server certificate issued by any subroot at least 2 of the following checks have to be completed successfully:
    1. E-Mail Ping sent to an administrative email address from WHOIS
    2. DNS Cookie
    3. HTTP Cookie
    4. Statement of at least 2 assurers about ownership/control of the domain name
    5. The RFC addresses.

AYE:

Philipp D, Alejandro Mery, Maurice, Lambert, Laura, Philipp G, Teus

Nay:

Abstain:

Closing date for votes was 24th of December 2008. CARRIED.

p20081016 All Information in Certificate is Verified

Teus: Resolved,

  1. Assurance, as per Assurance Programme and Assurance Policy (e.g. Name).
  2. "Evaluation" as per Certification Practice Statement (e.g. domains, email address).
  3. Control, as per Certification Practice Statement (e.g. serial numbers, etc.).
    • (The word "Evaluation" may be replaced at a later time by a term more suitable.)

Aye:

Maurice, Laura, Teus, Philipp D, Philipp G, Lambert, Sam, Tomáš, Ted, Greg

Nay:

Abstain:

p20080920 Organisation Assurance sub-policy for Europe voted to DRAFT

Teus: Resolved,

Aye:

Sam, Teus, Philipp

Nay:

Abstain:

Votes: consensus

p20080917.1 Drop wildcards for unassured Members

Iang: Resolved,

Aye:

Laura, Hans Verbeek, Ted, Teus, Philipp, Greg, Guillaume,

Nay:

Pete Stephenson, Sam,

Abstain:

Philipp G

Carried. Votes: 7 Ayes. 2 Nays. 1 Abstained.

20100708: Iang Following request for review of thread by Philipp G, the text and subjectAltNames was dropped from decision (2nd and 3rd words).

p20080917.2 Expiry times on Certs

Iang: Resolved,

Aye:

Pete Stephenson, Greg, Ted, Teus, Philipp G

Nay:

Abstain:

Votes: 5 Ayes.

Note, this motion originally included 12 months only for code-signing

p20080712.1 Assurance Policy

Teus: Resolved,

Aye:

Ron Pettigrew, Philipp, Lambert, Fred Trotter, Robert Cruikshank, Greg, Guillaume, Ted, Pete Stephenson,

Nay:

Sam,

Abstain:

Votes: 9 Ayes, 1 Nay, 4 Abstentions. It is not clear who the Abstentions were.

p20080429.1 Organisation Assurance Sub-Policy for Ireland

Teus: Resolved, that:

Aye:

Robert Cruikshank, Sam, Teus, Andrew

Nay:

Abstain:

Votes: 4 Ayes, no rejections or further comments.

p20080402.1 Organisation Assurance Sub-Policy for Australia

Teus: Resolved,

Aye:

Robert Cruikshank, Sam, Teus

Nay:

Abstain:

Votes: 3 Ayes, no rejections or further comments.

p20080401.1 Policy on Organisation Assurance

Teus: Resolved,

Aye:

Teus, Fred Trotter, Sam, Greg, Robert Cruikshank,

Nay:

Abstain:

Vote closed: only Ayes.

p20080401.2 Proposal to drop Date of Birth

Teus: Resolved,

Aye:

Teus, Ted, Greg, Evaldo,

Nay:

Sam, Philipp, Fred Trotter,

Abstain:

Vote closed: 4 Ayes, 3 Nays. some not clear votes (Rasika): 1 Aye, 2 Nay

Conclusion: Not Carried. DoB is not dropped.

p20080308.1 Organisation Assurance sub-policy for Austria

Philipp G: Resolved, that:

Aye:

Teus, Philipp,

Nay:

Abstain:

Votes closed: Ayes: 2 from Austria, no rejects or comments.

p20080204.1 Policy On Policy

Iang: Resolved,

Aye:

Jens Paul, Teus, Ted, Michael Diederich, Philipp G

Nay:

Abstain:

Carried. Vote called, closed.

p20080128.1 Assurers are individuals not organisations

Iang: Resolved,

  1. Assurers are individuals, not organisations.
  2. Organisation Assurers are individuals, too.
  3. Organisation Assurance does not rely on web-of-trust, but instead relies on quality processes.

In the above, _individuals_ is synonymous with _natural persons_ and _organisations_ is synonymous with _legal persons_ being organisations that are legally separated from people.

Aye:

Philipp D, Ted, Philipp G, Greg, Teus, Jens Paul, Lambert

Nay:

Abstain:

Carried. Closed.

p20080109.1 CCA to POLICY status

Teus: Resolved,

Aye:

Teus, Ted, Jens Paul, Robert Cruikshank, Brian Henson,

Nay:

Abstain:

This means that the DRAFT copy moves to the POLICY copy.

Carried. 5 Ayes, 0 Nays. called, last call, final call.

p20080106.1 Members

Iang: Resolved,

Aye:

Ted, Lambert, Greg, Evaldo, Brian Henson, Teus, Jens Paul, Michael Diederich, Ron Pettigrew,

Nay:

Abstain:

p20080104.1 Contributions

Teus: Resolved,

Aye:

Teus, Philipp G, Michael Diederich, Ted, Jens Paul

Nay:

Abstain:

(5 Ayes, 0 Nays)

Carried. started, last call.

p20071217.1 Multiple Names

Teus: Resolved,

Commentary. This means that the accounts and Assurance process should be adjusted to cope with multiple names. Assurance Policy suggests 50 points for each name.

This vote was called but also declared as consensus: 1, 2. The vote was not properly documented in mail archives, therefore would not be called a voted decision.

p20071107.1 Privacy

Jens Paul: Resolved, that:

1.4  Privacy

You give rights to CAcert to store, verify and process and publish your data in accordance with policies in force. These rights include shipping the data to foreign countries for system administration, support and processing purposes. Such shipping will only be done among CAcert Community administrators and Assurers.

Privacy is further covered in the Privacy Policy (PP => COD 5).

Aye:

Jens Paul, Teus, Greg

Nay:

Abstain:

Carried. Ayes: 3. started (actually, it was started in Advisory meeting and this post carried it into Policy Group, from memory, iang), closed.

p20071207.1 Organisation Assurance sub-policy for the Netherlands

Teus: Resolved,

called. Decided on policy email list by consensus, no votes seen. The last version of the sub-policy.

p20071022 Organisation Assurance sub-policy for Germany

Teus: Resolved,

Aye:

Jac Kersing, Sebastian, Jens Paul, Teus

Nay:

Abstain:

Carried. called and closed.

Added retrospectively from mail archives 20100610. This decision was redone from one improperly recorded in TOP.


Some reminders of policy decision taken by other means

p20070918.1 Policy on Organisation Assurance

Jens Paul: Resolved,

Decided upon by decision of CAcert TOP meeting September 2007: m20070918.x.

p-XXX-20070918.2 Organisation Assurance sub-policy for Germany

Jens Paul: Resolved,

Decision made in CAcert TOP meeting Septmber 2007, m20070918.y but unrecorded. Re-done on policy group, 22nd of October 2007 on Policy email list as decision #p20071022 above.

deprecate this section.

m20060629 Privacy Policy (PP) (COD5)

Info out of https://svn.cacert.org/CAcert/Policies/ControlledDocumentList.html


PolicyDecisions (last edited 2014-10-16 05:42:18 by EvaStöwe)