Arbitrations/a20101114.1

Before: Arbitrator UlrichSchroeter (A), Respondent: CAcert (R), Claimant: Dirk A (C), Case: a20101114.1

History Log

2010-11-14 (issue.c.o) case [s20101114.18]
2010-11-14 (A): added to wiki, I'll take care as A for this case
2010-11-14 (CM): I'll take care about this case as CM
2010-11-14 (C): accepts CCA/DRP at f2f meeting at OpenRhein-Ruhr 2010 event in front of (A)
2010-11-14 (A): (C), (CM), (A), Mendel from (Critical Team) meets at OpenRhein-Ruhr 2010 for interactive session

Adhoc interactive SQL-queries to follow proposed Software-Assessment and Update Cycle Procedure, all parties sitting around a round table, and walking thru the procedure

The intermediate ruling at interactive session dated 2010-11-14 at OpenRhein-Ruhr event has been conducted by SP/SM.
At no time within the meeting one of the participients has access to the critical system except Critical Admin.
All activities of Critical Admin has been ordered by (A), observed by (CM)
One interactive SQL query has been requested by (C), reviewed by (A), ordered by (A) to (Critical Admin), executed by (Critical Admin).
SQL query result set has been reviewed by (A): contains no personal identifiable informations.
So I order hereby: SQL query result set can be made publicitly available (eg for Software-Assessors, Developers) by (Critical Admin)
The interactive session procedure followed SP/SM rules, so all were in compliance to SP/SM

Frankfurt/Main, 2010-11-15

2010-11-14 (Critical Admin): sends result set to: (Critical Admin team), (C), (CM), (A) by email
2010-11-15 (A): sends ruling to (C), (CM), (Crtical Admin)
2010-11-15 (A): case closed

a20090810.4	Emergency access to CAcert critical systems
a20090810.1	Emergency code change without dual control
a20100822.1	SQL query