Arbitration / Training
The Training Course for Case Managers and Arbitrators
"Delete my Account" user is Assurer
- Assurer has given Assurances
- Arbitrator has to request for the CAP forms by default
- Options for the Assurer with "Delete my Account" request
- To keep the CAP forms
- Assurer has to keep the CAP forms (obligation)
- obligation: to keep the CAP forms, to keep his email in good working order
- Assurer has to answer on future Arbitrator requests
- risk: Assurer may find himself subject to Arbitration
- liability: potential risk on liabilities continues, eg by not answering on future arbitrators request
- Assurer has to keep the CAP forms (obligation)
- To send-in the CAP forms
- Assurer transfers CAP forms to an Arbitrator, back to CAcert
- obligation (to keep the CAP forms for 7 years): ends with transfer to an Arbitrator
- to keep his email in good working order probably is less a problem, as contacting the assurer is only need for a liability issue
- requests by future Arbitrators goes to the Arbitrator in the "Delete my Account" case
- risk: reduced risk by the Assurer to may find himself subject to Arbitration
- liability: potential risk on liabilities decreases, eg Arbitrator has to answer on future arbitrators requests regarding given assurances by former Assurer
- Assurer transfers CAP forms to an Arbitrator, back to CAcert
- Revoke Assurances ???
- Account removals goes thru Arbitration to protect the WoT
- Arbitration is about to protect the Assurances framework
- This needs to be brought in compliance with Assurers wish to leave the community
- To keep the CAP forms
Why Revocation of Assurance Points is no option ?
- Assurer who wants his account deleted has following list of Assurances Given
Date
Who
E-Mail
Points
Location
Method
Revoke
21.02.2008
User A
user.a@email
0
somewhere X
Face to Face Meeting
Revoke
20.01.2009
User B
user.b@email
35
somewhere Y
Face to Face Meeting
Revoke
- Scenario 1: To revoke Assurances of Assurer with "Delete my Account" request. Following an Assuree's account (User A) with 5 Assurances received. Line 4 is the Assurer with the "Delete my Account" request.
line
1. pts issued
2. transfered pts
3. action 1
4. pts after revocation
5. actions to take
6. re-issue pts
7. result
1
35
35
35
35
2
35
35
35
35
3
35
30
30
30
4
20
0
revoke
=> results in
0
0
0
5
30
0
0
0
0
total
100
100
100
nothing to do, so therefor no problem
- Scenario 2: To revoke Assurances of Assurer with "Delete my Account" request. Following an Assuree's account (User B ) with 5 Assurances received. Line 2 is the Assurer with the "Delete my Account" request.
line
1. pts issued
2. transfered pts
3. action 1
4. pts after revocation
5. actions to take
6. re-issue pts
7. result
1
35
35
35
35
2
35
35
revoke
=> results in
0
0
3
35
30
30
30
4
20
0
0
(A) contact assurer
(S) revoke assurance
(AS4) reapply assurance20
20
5
30
0
0
(A) contact assurer
(S) revoke assurance
(AS5) reapply assurance30
15
total
100
65
100
- Assurers issued # of points onto Assurees account (line 1-5)
- Transfered points: eg. line 4: you've issued 20 pts, rounded down to 0
- revoke assurance of Assurer who requested "delete my account" (line 2)
- result of pts on assurees account after assurer (who requested "delete my account") pts revocation (line 2)
- arbitrator has to order several actions for account pts corrections (line 4 + 5)
- re-applying assurances to correct the assurees account pts count by Assurer #4 and #5 (line 4 + 5)
- pts count after re-applying assurances by old assurers after corrections (line 1-5)
several corrections needs to be done in Arbitration process, to protect the Assurees account
Discovery
- Request Assurances Given from Support
- Count Assurances Given Total
- Count Assurances Given with Points GT 0
- Each Assurees Account needs to be reviewed