. To '''[[Brain/CAcertInc/Committee/MeetingAgendasAndMinutes| Meeting Agendas & Minutes]]''' - '''[[Brain/CAcertInc/Committee/ActionItems|Current Action Items]]''' - ''' Back to [[OverviewProjectsBoard|Projects Board Overview]]'''

----
 Table of Contents  <<TableOfContents(3)>>
----

## <<Include(OverviewProjectsBoard/Glossary)>>

== 12.1 Arbitration ==

<<Anchor(table1)>>
 ||<tablewidth="98%" -5 rowclass="rcdaybreak">'''12.1 Arbitration'''|| {*} ||
 ||<60%> Arbitrator appointments ||<15%> [[https://community.cacert.org/board/motions.php?motion=m20091122.5|m20091122.5]] ||<10%> 2009-11-26 ||<4%> (./) ||<7%> ||<4%> ||
 || DRO Appointment Lambert Hofstra || [[https://community.cacert.org/board/motions.php?motion=m20100103.2|m20100103.2]] || 2010-01-07 || (./) || || ||
 || approx 1 /!\ working arbitrators - more volunteers needed || ||<10%> 2011-10-22 || {-} || ||  ||
 || .. || || ||  || || ||
  . '''''table 1'''''

  . '''Notes'''
   . m20091122.5 - Confirm the motions m20091121.1, m20091119.1, m20091117.1 being motions to approve Alexander P, Walter G, and Martin G as Arbitrators, with immediate effect.
   . m20100103.2 - resolved, that Lambert Hofstra be appointed as Dispute Resolution Officer,and further resolved that Nick Bebout\'s resignation is accepted, and he is thanked for efforts.
   . Info: [[ArbitrationForum|Arbitration Forum]]
   . Info: [[Arbitrations/Arbitrators|List of Arbitrators and Case Managers]]
   . Info: [[https://wiki.cacert.org/Arbitrations|List of Pending Cases]]
   . 80 cases, 30 running, 41 cases closed within last 5 months (2010-03-15)
   . 2010: Jan +10, Feb +20, Mar +15

  . '''Status'''
   . [[Arbitrations/a20100210.2|Precedent-Case]] and [[Arbitrations/Training/Lesson12|Lesson 12 - Arbitration - Precedents]]
     * [[https://lists.cacert.org/wws/arc/cacert-de/2010-03/msg00040.html|mailing-list-de 2010-03-17]] - quotation Andreas Bäss: "Wer entscheidet, ob ein Schiedspruch eines Arbitrators Vorbildfunktion hat oder nicht? Ist die erste Entscheidung zu einem Themengebiet automatisch der Wegweiser für alle folgenden Fälle, auch wenn darüber unter den Schiedsrichtern unterschiedliche Meinungen herrschen?"
       * How is the process for precedence-cases? Is there a discussion (community, arbitrators ...)? Who will decide about that? If there is one, will be all related documents updated (Handbook, Info on website, documents etc)?

   . '''Volunteers needed''' 

<<BR>>

 . '''FY 2011-2012'''
 ||<|2>'''Cases closed<<BR>>from year''' ||<-6>'''2011''' ||<-6>'''2012''' ||<|2>'''Still open/<<BR>>running totals''' ||
 || Jul || Aug || Sep || Oct || Nov || Dec || Jan || Feb || Mar || Apr || May || Jun ||
 || '''2009'''  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||   0 ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  5 {r} ||
 || '''2010'''  ||  0  ||  4  ||  1  ||  2  ||  0  ||  0  ||   0 ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  || 21 {r} ||
 || '''2011'''  ||  2  ||  0  ||  7  ||  4  ||  7  ||  5  ||  11 ||  3  ||  2  ||  1  ||  1  ||  0  || 32 ||
 || '''2012'''  ||    ||     ||     ||     ||     ||     ||    0 ||  0  ||  1  ||  1  ||  3  ||  1  || 33 ||
 || '''Total'''  ||  2  ||  4  ||  8  ||  6  ||  7  ||  5  || 11 ||  3  ||  3  ||  2  ||  4  ||  1  || 91 ||
 || ''Total New''  ||  0  ||  10 ||  7  || 10  || 16  ||  7  || 8 ||  4  ||  8  ||  6  ||  6  ||  7  || 89 ||
 || ''Active Arbitrators'' || 1 || 1 || 1 || 1  ||  2  ||  2  ||   0 ||  2  ||  2  ||  1  ||  2  ||  0  || 1   ||

 . '''FY 2012-2013'''
<<Anchor(table2)>>
 ||<|2>'''Cases closed<<BR>>from year''' ||<-6>'''2012''' ||<-6>'''2013''' ||<|2>'''Still open/<<BR>>running totals''' ||
 || Jul || Aug || Sep || Oct || Nov || Dec || Jan || Feb || Mar || Apr || May || Jun ||
 || '''2009'''  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||   0 ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  5 {r} (-0) ||
 || '''2010'''  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||   0 ||  1  ||  1  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  || 18 {r} (-3) ||
 || '''2011'''  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  ||   2 ||  0  ||  2  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  || 27 {r} (-5) ||
 || '''2012'''  ||  1  ||  1  ||  1  ||  2  ||  1  ||  2  ||   0 ||  0  ||  3  ||  0  ||  0  ||  0  || 37     (+4) ||
 || '''2013'''  ||     ||     ||     ||     ||     ||     ||   0 ||  1  ||  0  ||  0  ||  1  ||  0  || 7           ||
 || '''Total'''  ||  1  ||  1  ||  1  ||  2  ||  1  ||  2  || 2 ||  2  ||  6  ||  0  ||  1  ||  0  || 94   (+3) ||
 || ''Total New''  ||  6  ||  2 ||  0  || 1  ||  6  ||  1  || 1 ||  1  ||  1  ||  3  ||  2  ||  1  || 25 ||
 || ''Active Arbitrators'' || 1 || 1 || 1 || 1  ||  1  ||  0  ||   1 ||  2  ||  2  ||  0  ||  1  ||  0  || 1-2  ||

  . '''''table 2'''''
<<BR>>
<<Anchor(table3)>>
 ||<tablewidth="70%" rowclass="rcdaybreak" >'''Arbitration''' ||<bgcolor="#00ff00": -3> ~-'''2012'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#FFFF00":> ~-'''2012'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#00ff00": -3> ~-'''2012'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#FFFF00":> ~-'''2012'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#00ff00": -3> ~-'''2013'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#FFFF00":> ~-'''2013'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#00ff00": -3> ~-'''2013'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#FFFF00":> ~-'''2013'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#00ff00": -3> ~-'''2013'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#FFFF00":> ~-'''2013'''-~ ||
 ||<rowbgcolor="#d2b48c" rowclass="rcdaybreak" : 20%>        ||<bgcolor="#00ff00" : 3%>~-'''Jul'''-~||<bgcolor="#00ff00": 3%>~-'''Aug'''-~||<bgcolor="#00ff00" : 3%>~-'''Sep'''-~||<bgcolor="#ffff00" : 3%>~-'''Q3'''-~||<bgcolor="#00ff00" : 3%>~-'''Oct'''-~||<bgcolor="#00ff00": 3%>~-'''Nov'''-~||<bgcolor="#00ff00" : 3%>~-'''Dec'''-~  ||<bgcolor="#ffff00" : 3%>~-'''Q4'''-~||<bgcolor="#00ff00" : 3%>~-'''Jan'''-~||<bgcolor="#00ff00" : 3%>~-'''Feb'''-~||<bgcolor="#00ff00" : 3%>~-'''Mar'''-~||<bgcolor="#ffff00" : 3%>~-'''Q1'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#00ff00" : 3%>~-'''Apr'''-~||<bgcolor="#00ff00" : 3%>~-'''May'''-~||<bgcolor="#00ff00" : 3%>~-'''Jun'''-~||<bgcolor="#ffff00" : 3%>~-'''Q2'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#00ff00" : 3%>~-'''Jul'''-~||<bgcolor="#00ff00" : 3%>~-'''Aug'''-~||<bgcolor="#00ff00" : 3%>~-'''Sep'''-~||<bgcolor="#ffff00" : 3%>~-'''Q3'''-~ ||
 ||~-New-~ = Total     ||<)>6  ||<)>2  ||<)>0   ||<)>8   ||<)>1 ||<)>6 ||<)>1  ||<)>8 ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>3 ||<)>3 ||<)>2 ||<)>1 ||<)>6 ||<)>2 ||<)>1 ||<)>3 ||<)>6 ||
 ||~-Running-~         ||<)>4 ||<)>0  ||<)>0  ||<)>4  ||<)>0 ||<)>5 ||<)>1 ||<)>5 ||<)>1 ||<)>0 ||<)>1 ||<)>2 ||<)>3 ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>5 ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>3 ||<)>5 ||
 ||~-Closed new-~          ||<)>1  ||<)>1  ||<)>1 ||<)>3  ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>0 ||<)>2 ||<)>0 ||<)>1 ||<)>0 ||<)>1 ||<)>0 ||<)>1 ||<)>0 ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>0 ||<)>0 ||<)>1 ||
 ||~-Closed total-~          ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>3 ||<)>2 ||<)>1 ||<)>2 ||<)>5 ||<)>2 ||<)>2 ||<)>6 ||<)>10 ||<)>0 ||<)>1 ||<)>0 ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>0 ||<)>1 ||<)>2 ||
 ||<rowbgcolor="#d2b48c">~-'''Total'''-~||<)>6  ||<)>2  ||<)>0  ||<)>'''8''' ||<)>1 ||<)>6 ||<)>1 ||<)>'''8''' ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>'''3''' ||<)>3 ||<)>2 ||<)>1 ||<)>'''6''' ||<)>2 ||<)>1 ||<)>3 ||<)>'''6''' ||
 ||<( -21> ~-'''Number Arbitrators'''-~ ||
 ||~-on list-~     ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15  ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15  ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||
 ||~-inactive-~    ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5  ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5  ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||
 ||~-busy-~        ||<)>9 ||<)>9 ||<)>9 ||<)>9  ||<)>9 ||<)>9 ||<)>10  ||<)>9 ||<)>9 ||<)>8 ||<)>8 ||<)>8 ||<)>10 ||<)>9 ||<)>10 ||<)>9 ||<)>9 ||<)>10 ||<)>9 ||<)>9 ||
 ||~-'''active'''-~||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>'''1''' ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||<)>0  ||<)>'''1''' ||<)>1 ||<)>2 ||<)>2 ||<)>'''2''' ||<)>0 ||<)>1 ||<)>0 ||<)>'''1''' ||<)>1 ||<)>0 ||<)>1 ||<)>'''1''' ||
  . '''''table 3'''''

<<BR>>
<<Anchor(table4)>>
 ||<tablewidth="70%" rowclass="rcdaybreak" >'''Arbitration'''||<: -2> ~-'''2007'''-~ ||<: -2> ~-'''2008'''-~ ||<: -2> ~-'''2008'''-~ ||<: -2> ~-'''2009'''-~  ||<: -2> ~-'''2009'''-~ ||<: -2> ~-'''2010'''-~ ||<: -2> ~-'''2010'''-~ ||<: -2> ~-'''2011'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#80ff80": -2> ~-'''2011'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#80ff80": -2> ~-'''2012'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#00ff00": -2> ~-'''2012'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#00ff00": -2> ~-'''2013'''-~ ||
 ||<rowbgcolor="#d2b48c" rowclass="rcdaybreak" : 20%>        ||<: 3%>~-'''Q3'''-~ ||<: 3%>~-'''Q4'''-~ ||<: 3%>~-'''Q1'''-~||<: 3%>~-'''Q2'''-~ ||<: 3%>~-'''Q3'''-~ ||<: 3%>~-'''Q4'''-~ ||<: 3%>~-'''Q1'''-~||<: 3%>~-'''Q2'''-~ ||<: 3%>~-'''Q3'''-~||<: 3%>~-'''Q4'''-~ ||<: 3%>~-'''Q1'''-~||<: 3%>~-'''Q2'''-~||<: 3%>~-'''Q3'''-~ ||<: 3%>~-'''Q4'''-~||<: 3%>~-'''Q1'''-~ ||<: 3%>~-'''Q2'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#80ff80" : 3%>~-'''Q3'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#80ff80" : 3%>~-'''Q4'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#80ff80" : 3%>~-'''Q1'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#80ff80" : 3%>~-'''Q2'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#ffff00" : 3%>~-'''Q3'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#ffff00" : 3%>~-'''Q4'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#ffff00" : 3%>~-'''Q1'''-~ ||<bgcolor="#ffff00" : 3%>~-'''Q2'''-~ ||
 ||~-New-~ = Total     ||<)>2  ||<)> 2 ||<)> 0 ||<)> 3 ||<)>1  ||<)> 0 ||<)> 8 ||<)> 38 ||<)> 29 ||<)> 33 ||<)> 55 ||<)> 16 ||<)> 23 ||<)> 17 ||<)> 35 ||<)> 24 ||<)>17  ||<)>33  ||<)>20  ||<)>19  ||<)>8 ||<)>8 ||<)>3 ||<)>6 ||
 ||~-Running-~         ||<)> 0 ||<)> 0 ||<)> 0 ||<)> 0 ||<)> 0 ||<)> 0 ||<)> 2 ||<)> 11 ||<)> 11 ||<)> 12 ||<)> 42 ||<)> 15 ||<)> 20 ||<)> 11 ||<)> 14 ||<)> 4 ||<)>15  ||<)> 4  ||<)>20  ||<)>16 ||<)>4 ||<)>5 ||<)>2 ||<)>5 ||
 ||~-Closed new-~          ||<)> 2 ||<)> 2 ||<)> 0 ||<)> 3 ||<)> 1 ||<)> 0 ||<)> 6 ||<)> 27 ||<)> 18 ||<)> 21 ||<)> 14 ||<)> 1 ||<)>  3 ||<)>  6 ||<)> 21 ||<)>  6 ||<)> 2   ||<)> 4  ||<)> 1  ||<)> 3  ||<)>3 ||<)>2 ||<)>1 ||<)>1 ||
 ||~-Closed total-~          ||<)> 2 ||<)> 2 ||<)> 0 ||<)> 3 ||<)>  ||<)>  ||<)>  ||<)>     ||<)>    ||<)>    ||<)>    ||<)>   ||<)>    ||<)>    ||<)> 48  ||<)> 20 ||<)> 14  ||<)> 18  ||<)> 17  ||<)> 7 ||<)>3 ||<)>5 ||<)>10 ||<)>1 ||
 ||<rowbgcolor="#d2b48c">~-'''Total'''-~||<)>'''2'''||<)>'''2''' ||<)>'''0'''||<)>'''3'''||<)>'''1'''||<)>'''0''' ||<)>'''8'''||<)>'''38'''||<)>'''29'''||<)>'''33''' ||<)>'''55''' ||<)>'''16''' ||<)>'''23''' ||<)>'''17''' ||<)>'''35''' ||<)>'''24''' ||<)>'''17'''  ||<)>'''33''' ||<)>'''20''' ||<)>'''19''' ||<)>'''8''' ||<)>'''8''' ||<)>'''3''' ||<)>'''6''' ||
 ||<( -25> ~-'''Number Arbitrators'''-~ ||
 ||~-on list-~     ||<)>  ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)>  ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)>14      ||<)>14 ||<)>12 ||<)>12 ||<)>12 ||<)>12 ||<)>12  ||<)>12  ||<)>12  ||<)>13  ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||<)>15 ||
 ||~-inactive-~    ||<)>  ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)>  ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)>4       ||<)>4 ||<)>3 ||<)>3 ||<)>3 ||<)>4 ||<)>5  ||<)>5  ||<)>5  ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||
 ||~-busy-~        ||<)>  ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)>  ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)>7       ||<)>6 ||<)>5 ||<)>5 ||<)>6 ||<)>6 ||<)>6  ||<)>5  ||<)>6  ||<)>7 ||<)>9 ||<)>9 ||<)>8 ||<)>9 ||
 ||~-'''active'''-~||<)>1  ||<)>1 ||<)>0 ||<)>3 ||<)>  ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)> ||<)>'''3''' ||<)>'''4''' ||<)>'''5''' ||<)>'''5''' ||<)>'''3''' ||<)>'''2''' ||<)>'''1'''  ||<)>'''2'''  ||<)>'''1'''  ||<)>'''1'''  ||<)>'''1'''  ||<)>'''1'''  ||<)>'''2'''  ||<)>'''1'''  ||
  . '''''table 4'''''


  . '''Notes'''
   . Please complete, thank you.

<<BR>>
<<Anchor(table5)>>
 ||<tablewidth="70%" rowclass="rcdaybreak" >'''Cases by Topics (open/running/closed)'''||<bgcolor="#FFFF00" :>'''~-Total'''-~|| ||<bgcolor="#00ff00" :>'''~-Position'''-~||
 ||~-Account deletion - Assurer Accounts-~ ||<)> 26 || ********** ||<)> 6 ||
 ||~-Account deletion - Non-Assurer Accounts-~ ||<)> 59 || *************** ||<)> '''1''' ||
 ||~-Account Cleanup-~ ||<)> 8 || ***** ||<)> 11 ||
 ||~-Name mismatching-~ ||<)> 30 || ************* ||<)> '''3''' ||
 ||~-Name order-~ ||<)> 9 || ****** ||<)> 10 ||
 ||~-Additional names-~ ||<)> 6 || **** ||<)> 12 ||
 ||~-Name Modifications Requested-~ ||<)> 49 || ************** ||<)> '''2''' ||
 ||~-Date of Birth-~ ||<)> 14 || ******* ||<)> 9 ||
 ||~-Other Assurer errors-~ ||<)> 19 || ********* ||<)> 7 ||
 ||~-CCA Violations-~ ||<)> 3 || ** ||<)> 14 ||
 ||~-Domain Disputes-~ ||<)> 2 || * ||<)> 15 ||
 ||~-Arbitrated Background Checks-~ ||<)> 17 || ******** ||<)> 8 ||
 ||~-System Tasks-~ ||<)> 28 || *********** ||<)> 5 ||
 ||~-Not covered yet - Others-~ ||<)> 30 || ************* ||<)> '''3''' ||
 ||~-External-~ ||<)> 5 || *** ||<)> 13 ||
 ||<rowbgcolor="#d2b48c">~-'''Total'''-~||<)>''' '''|| || ||
  . '''''table 5'''''

  . '''Notes'''
   . Please complete, thank you.

----
 ''' Back to [[OverviewProjectsBoard|Projects Board Overview]]'''
----
 . CategoryProjects