Before: Arbitrator name arbitor (A), Respondent: Martin S (R), Claimant: CAcert (C1), Case: a20120113.1

Former parties: Werner D. for Support (C2).

History Log

Link to Arbitration case a20120113.1 (Private Part), Access for (CM) + (A) only

EOT Private Part

Original Dispute

Discovery

FrOSCon 2016 session - future of 25 arbitration cases from leaving team members

At FrOSCon 2016 members of Arbitration, Board and Support took part in a session on possible withdrawal of cases by CAcert(Support)/CAcert and prior clarification about claimants. On 2016-08-23 the initial report of that FrOSCon 2016 session, Protocol - FrOSCon session - future of 25 arbitration cases from leaving team members, was posted on the board and arbitration mailing lists for review and discussion.

The executive "decisions" taken during the FrOSCon 2016 Session (and also regarding additional cases) were confirmed by board motion m20160921.2 on 2016-09-25:

Resolved, that board withdraws the cases as mentioned in the emails https://lists.cacert.org/wws/arc/cacert-board/2016-08/msg00009.html and https://lists.cacert.org/wws/arc/cacert-board/2016-08/msg00017.html acting for CAcert as claimant of that cases.

The detailed background, proceedings and the initial report of the FrOSCon 2016 session are publicly available as FrOSCon 2016 Session Report.

FrOSCon 2016 session - review of case a20120113.1 - "CCA violation, Close Account"

At the FrOSCon 2016 Session case a20120113.1 - "CCA violation, Close Account" was put up for review as all who were present at the session agreed that it fitted the criteria for review:

For this case this meant that Support would now assume the role of claimant and that the original claimant should be considered as former claimant, having been dismissed from the dispute.

The subsequent review of this case at FrOSCon 2016 made Support decide to withdraw the case as claimant as shown by the relevant section of the FrOSCon 2016 report posted on the board and arbitration mailinglists on 2016-08-23:

3. https://wiki.cacert.org/Arbitrations/a20120113.1
-------------------------------------------------------------------
"CCA violation, Close Account"

 * summary of dispute:
"Dispute against [a member] since he seemingly uses an account with fake
data. His account shall be closed and his certificates revoked." - This
was the reaction to a mail send by that member with the request to help
to reset the password where the user had issues to enter the correct
birth date in the automated process.

 * support: please hand back case to support, as there is another
"policy" within Support that names a lot of other options in such
situations to handle such situations (for example to propose request to 
close account so that another can be created, but maybe there were only
some issues with entering the birth date).
-> withdraw
 * board: ok

FrOSCon 2016 session - review of case a20120113.1 - "CCA violation, Close Account" - comments received

The review of this case as reported on the board and arbitration mailinglists didn't lead to comments.

Ruling

None - claimant C1 withdrew case on 2016-08-20.

Similiar Cases

a20091206.1

Dispute agains ... on violating CCA

a20100701.1

violation of CCA 2.5.2


Arbitrations/a20120113.1 (last edited 2016-10-22 12:55:08 by PietStarreveld)