* Case Number: a20100116.1
  * Status: closed
  * Claimants: Philipp Gühring
  * Respondents: Markus Warg
  * Case Manager: MartinGummi
  * Arbitrator: UlrichSchroeter
  * Date of arbitration start: 2010-02-05
  * Date of ruling: 2010-02-21
  * Case closed: 2010-02-21
  * Complaint: Arbitrated Background Check over Markus Warg

{{{
2010-01-16
I have been asked (m20091220.2) to propose new team members for the
Software Assessment team. I talked to the suggested candidates, roughly
evaluated their qualifications and time-budgets, and came to the
conclusion that we should start the process with Alexander Prinsier and
Markus Warg.

Therefore please start the arbitrated Background Checks on Alexander
Prinsier and Markus Warg now.

Best regards,
PG
}}}

  * Relief: TBD

Before: Arbitrator UlrichSchroeter (A), Respondent: Markus Warg (R), Claimant: Philipp Gühring (C), Case: a20100116.1


== History Log ==
 . 2010-01-16 (UlrichSchroeter): added to wiki, request for CM / A
 . 2010-02-05 (A): I'll take care about this case as (A)
 . 2010-02-05 (A): sent init mailing to (R) with request for CV
 . 2010-02-05 (A): sent init mailing to (C)
 . 2010-02-05 (R): I accept the arbitration under the CCA / DRP
 . 2010-02-05 (C): I accept the arbitration under the CCA / DRP
 . 2010-02-06 (A): rcvd CV / references contacts list from (R)
 . 2010-02-07 (A): asked Ian, to becoming the interviewer for this case
 . 2010-02-07 (A): asked Martin, to becoming the (CM) for this case
 . 2010-02-07 (Ian): accepts to be the interviewer in this case 
 . 2010-02-07 (CM): I'll take care about this case as (CM)
 . 2010-02-07 (A): interview happens in a face-2-face meeting at [[events/FOSDEM2010|Fosdem]] with (R), interviewer, (A)
 . 2010-02-09 (A): sent CV / references contacts list and interview transscript to interviewer and (CM)
 . 2010-02-09 (A): rcvd comments and notes on transcript from interviewer

== Discovery ==

== Ruling ==
 The background check has not revealed any material issues in 
conflict with a role under Security Policy (SP).

 During the interview, a relationship to a commercial CA was 
discovered.  This was observed during the interview, and discussed.  The 
relationship has no apparent force.  We therefore conclude that although 
a CoI exists in theory, it does not represent a material threat to CAcert.

 Investigation of potential weaknesses in social engineering 
revealed that (C) had little familiarity with this topic.  I recommend 
training in this area.  A first lesson in this area was given by 
interviewer.

 (C) was questioned on background related to anticipated subject 
matter (Software).  Knowledge is based on experienced rather than on 
academic training.

Frankfurt/Main, Feb 21st 2010
Ulrich Schroeter

== Execution ==
 . 2010-02-21 (A): sent out ruling to (C), (R), (CM), interviewer
 . 2010-02-21 (A): case closed.

== Similiar Cases ==
|| [[Arbitrations/a20091209.1|a20091209.1]] || [[Arbitrations/a20091209.1|Arbitrated Background Check over Wolfgang Kasulke]] ||
|| [[Arbitrations/a20091215.1|a20091215.1]] || [[Arbitrations/a20091215.1|Arbitrated Background Check over Martin Schulze]] ||

----
 . CategoryArbitration
 . [[CategoryArbCaseSystemABC]]